Archives for category: family

GoodnessLast week marked 7 years since Amy was Stillborn. We have a tradition of going somewhere different within an hour or so of Manchester as a family so we went to York this time.

Since I started going to the Third Order meetings I have struggled with a line we say together as part of the Liturgy we do:

You are good, all good, supremely good,
Lord God, living and true.

To begin with I simply didn’t say it because I couldn’t admit that God was good. How could he be good and let Amy die, causing Mary-Lou, myself and others so much suffering? I still felt angry.

But eventually I decided that I wanted to be able to say this about God again, so I forced myself to say these lines with my fellow Tertiaries. I don’t think I feel as angry towards God, but I am still very confused.

This evening I was reading St Francis’ paraphrase of The Lord’s Prayer and got stuck again at this line:

… you, Lord, are the supreme good, the eternal good, and it is from you all good comes, and without you there is no good.

I began asking the question “If all good comes from you, and without you there is no good, then where were you when Amy died? In that moment of non-goodness, where were you, God?”

In the immediate days and weeks following Amy’s stillbirth, I felt God close to me and it was a source of comfort. After a few weeks, I no longer felt him near as my anger and confusion grew. So if God’s goodness was close to Mary-Lou and myself afterwards, where was it when Amy died?

I can only assume that God and his goodness was with Amy and us when she died. Even writing that makes be begin to feel angry again. But my question has shifted to Why? It’s the classic Why? which ties suffering and death with a loving, all-powerful, good God and leaves the big question mark.

I think I’ve accepted knowing that I will never know the answer to this giant question. Perhaps an answer would add to my confusion and pain – I don’t know.

a-beautiful-death-tshirt-logo-hrI am very slowly still making my way through the book “Franciscan Spirituality” and have just read the chapter “Sister Bodily Death” at a poignant time for me.

We moved house 1 year ago this Friday to Northern Moor in Manchester. When we went to introduce ourselves to our neighbours we discovered that one of our neighbours, Rob, had Chronic Progressive MS. He was bed bound in his purpose built extension and was a heavy chain smoker, with the smell often drifting into our house.

I felt quite challenged about my response to his condition as a neighbour. I was scared that such a needy person would be very demanding of me and my time so I didn’t really want to form a relationship with Rob. But I knew I had to face this challenge and my fear / prejudice and make an effort to spend time with Rob and let him know I cared for him.

I also reflected on my past record with my friendships, how for a long time I had only contacted friends if I needed or wanted something from them (what does that say about my understanding of friendship?!). I realised that any friendship I built with Rob would be very one sided, I wouldn’t get anything back from this friendship, and this made me determined to invest in this relationship as a challenge to myself to oppose my self-centered ideas of friendships and relationships.

Of course, I cared for Rob from the beginning, feeling sympathy for him and circumstances. I knew that his family didn’t visit often and the only people he really spoke to were his carers. So I decided to try to see him one evening every 2 weeks.

Getting to know Rob was a joy. He was a huge Manchester City FC fan and a true no-nonsense Mancunian. I learned more about his condition, his history, family, interests and of course Man City. There were often times when he explained he wasn’t doing as good or the blunt horror of his condition and I didn’t know what to say. At the time, the idea of offering my prayers felt very shallow, both becuase I was struggling with my relationship with God (still am!) and because I had no faith that any prayers would change his condition. Chronic Progressive MS means that it only gets worse, there’s no medically known way to reverse the progression.

Mary-Lou, Toby, Milo and I went round to celebrate his 50th birthday and at Christmas time and he clearly loved chatting to, and winding up, Toby and Milo. He always asked after them and Mary-Lou when I went round and was concerned that we settled into our new house and area quickly.

Rob had 2 stays in St. Ann’s Hospice and I took the boys along when I went to visit. On his second visit, he didn’t return home after 2 weeks, the normal length of his stays, so a week later I called the Hospice and they said he’d been taken to Wythenshawe hospital for treatment. On Friday 22nd March, Rob’s other neighbour came round to tell us that Doctors had said Rob was likely to die in the coming hours. That night I went tot he Hospital to see Rob.

I felt very nervous and emotional going to see him. I didn’t know what to think or what I should say, or who else would be there, or if Rob would be conscious or if he may have already died. On the way there, the phrase “The Lord is my Shepherd” came to me after seeing the logo for a company called Shepherd on the side of the building. I realised that there was no way I could predict or even begin to process the multitude of possible scenarios I was about to encounter and that I would only find peace by trusting God to be my Shepherd and guide me through whatever I faced at the Hospital.

Rob’s brother and a friend were by his bedside when I arrived. Rob had an oxygen mask on and was obviously finding it hard to breathe. Whenever he breathed out, his body would almost collapse and the bed shook. Rob’s brother Stuart told Rob I was here so I said hello and Rob moved his head and opened his eyes to try to see me and murmured some noises, probably saying hello and thanks.

I stayed there for a hour or so, sporadically speaking with whoever came in and out of the room then being silent. I felt very uncomfortable about the way people were talking about Rob, as though he had already died even though he was right next to us, remembering moments and attributes of his. I thought that I would hate that on my death bed.

I had one moment of about 5 minutes on my own with Rob, so I decided to chat to him about the things we would usually speak of, about the changes we were making to our house, how the boys and Mary-Lou were doing, etc. Then I told him I had been and will be praying for him. He immediately tried to turn his head and say something which felt alot like thanks, or appreciation of some sort.

When I was going to go, I didn’t want to say “See you soon, mate” or something glib like that. I found it very hard to just say goodbye.

Rob died around midday the next day.

I was invited to go to his funeral at the Southern Cemetery which I waned to do. The funeral was lead by the chaplain of St. Ann’s Hospice who told a story which made me cry. He said that during his last stay at St. Ann’s, Rob had asked the chaplain if they could speak alone. Rob explained he had been thinking about death and was scared. After some discussion the chaplain offered to pray with Rob and on the way back to Rob’s room, he thanked the chaplain and said he felt much more peaceful as a result. It reminded me of his appreciation of my prayers and I welled up at that Rob had felt the peace of God and at the idea that he had been blessed by me too.

I have no doubt the my grief over Rob’s death has raised unprocessed grief over losing Amy. It has reminded me of other friends I have known who have died – Charlotte from the skatepark, Hio Yin who I lived with in Carlton Avenue, and bubbly Faith who I knew at University.

Francis embraced Death as a Sister, and the chapter in the “Franciscan Spirituality” book mention that John Wesley said of his Methodists “Our people die well”. I would like a good death. I don’t really know what that would look like, but I do not want to be scared at that time. Like Francis I want to rejoice in what Christ has done in and through me.

Rob’s death has caused me to ponder about what I will leave here on earth after I have gone, what my legacy will be. In thinking through the social changes I would like to be a part of, the broken and the weak whom I want to be a blessing too and all the hopes I have to “change the world”, I keep coming back to Toby and Milo. They are my legacy and what I will leave here to hopefully be a blessing to many others. I want to invest my love, energy and time into them, though as any parent knows, it is hard work!

My local Third Order has been going through the book “Franciscan Spirituality” by Brother Ramon over the last months and discussing a chapter each month. Since I find very little time for reading books at this stage in my life, I’ve always been behind.

During my Franciscan time today I read the chapter “The Evangelical Counsels” which explored and explained the vows of Poverty, Chastity and Obedience within the Franciscan Order.

I’ve always been drawn to the challenge and counter-cultural aspect of Poverty and I hope that my family and I learn to joyfully live much more simple and uncluttered lives. It is certainly a confusing idea at the moment when we are moving to a larger house and where Toby and Milo, 3 and 1, have (and need?) so many toys and books and play things. I’m also aware that Poverty challenges me, and our society, in terms of our technology, devices and gadgets. It’s not so much the cost of these things than the distractions they provide making our lives more complex rather than more simple.

Chastity always felt like the easy one, suggesting simple faithfulness to Mary-Lou. But Brother Ramon suggests:

We know that all our relationships, all our creativity, inspiration, and appreciation of things good, true and beautiful are suffused by our sexuality, which lends warmth, tenderness, and enchantment.

Celibacy, in such a context, is not a denial of sexuality, but a way of sharing that has not only an intellectual, but also an emotional and tender dimension.

My sexuality feels very shallow in this light!

The thing which stuck with me most from Brother Ramon’s writing about Obedience was the origin of the word.

The word obedience comes from the Latin root audire – to hear, to listen. The prefix, making it ob-audire, signifies instant and alert listening.

So the vow of Obedience is to be alert to the voice of The Spirit at all times, and react out of love for God, something I eagerly want to learn.

It’s been 5 months since I last blogged here. I feel bad about not having blogged about alot of stuff I’ve thought over that time, but one of the things I’m learning is that most things are temporary, especially when you have a baby!

It was around 5 months ago that I had a bit of an identity crisis. The root of this clearly stem from losing my daughter Amy over 2 years ago, and coincided with my son Toby being born. His birth threw up a few things for me including who I am. I’m now Toby’s Dad, and I’m Amy’s grieving Dad. The joy and delight I have in Toby has left little emotional time to dwell on my grief and the tension between a grieving and joyful Dad has left me a bit confused.

It was around this time that I realised that I didn’t feel I belonged to the group of Christians I’ve known for the last 8 years. This was because after losing Amy, the dawning realisation that I had new and unique needs met a dawning realisation that these needs were not being met by this community of Christians I was part of. This group is fairly homogeneous since we all met at University and are of similar ages. Since we are all still young, and nobody had lost a child, we didn’t have any experience to know how to care for Mary-Lou and myself so we were were not able to be carried by the group. This wasn’t helped by not knowing myself how I could be helped. The pain and confusion of not having been carried by our Christian community left me feeling I didn’t belong. 

So I began getting busy, not knowing at the time that I was searching for an identity, something I could point to and say “This is what Ben is about, this is what he does”. I started Guerrilla Gardening in Moss Side. I started helping a project collecting fruit from Manchester gardens to distribute to the poor and hungry. I got funding for a High Definition Camcorder to record Asylum Seekers telling their stories. I started a podcast exploring the implications of Shane Claiborne’s book “The Irresistible Revolution”. I became co-ordinator of my street’s Home Watch. I started planning the Parliament Protest. I got pretty busy all of a sudden and had less and less time for Mary-Lou and Toby.

In the end I gave some of that up, cut back on others, and finished the rest. I’m not as busy as I was (outside of work) and I’m looking forward to discovering routines and patterns (temporary of course) of time and activity with Mary-Lou and Toby.

I’ve not discovered my identity, I’m sure I’ll be figuring it out the rest of my life. But for now it feels good and proper that I rest and invest in the place I have as Mary-Lou’s husband and Amy and Toby’s Dad.